About: alexadmin alexadmin

Website:
Bio:

Posts by alexadmin alexadmin:

Court Allows Gutschmidt to Amend Pleadings and Name Escalante Golf Companies

Posted on: 26 Oct 2026

Ellensburg, Washington Following a hearing on Friday, October 23, 2026, in Kittitas County Superior Court, the court granted Plaintiff Penny Gutschmidt’s Motion for Leave to Amend Pleadings.  Gutschmidt brought this motion after the court’s earlier decision to stay Tumble Creek Golf’s Motion for Summary Judgment in August. With the order entered by Judge James Kitcham on Friday, Gutschmidt is allowed to amend her original pleadings against Tumble Creek Golf, LLC and to include new defendants and new claims in addition to the original claims for violations of Washington’s Consumer Protection Act 19.85 RCW (“CPA”) among other relief being sought, including the certification of a class on behalf of current and former members of the Tumble Creek Club. Following the court’s entry of the order, Gutschmidt filed her First Amended Complaint (see below). The First Amended Complaint now names Suncadia Resort, LLC, Escalante Golf, LLC, Escalante Tumble Creek, LLC, Escalante Tumble Creek Development, LLC and Escalante Tumble Creek Holdings, LLC; LDD Tumble Creek Manager, Inc. was dropped as a party from the lawsuit. The amendment to the pleadings was prompted by the sale of the Tumble Creek Club and its membership agreements as part of Suncadia Resort’s transaction with Escalante Golf in July 2026 (see below). With this court decision, litigation over the Tumble Creek Club’s membership plan will continue to move forward. Gutschmidt’s motion for certification of a class and Tumble Creek Golf’s motion for summary judgment remain pending until all of the newly named parties can be before the court. On October 30, 2025, Penny Gutschmidt, is a former resident of Tumble Creek, filed suit in Kittitas County Superior Court against Tumble Creek Club, LLC and others alleging among other things that that Tumble Creek’s Membership Agreement violates Washington’s Consumer Protection Act, Ch. 19.86 RCW. In addition to her own personal claims against Tumble Creek Club, Gutschmidt’s Complaint alleges that she is only one of many affected by the Membership Agreement and seeks to certify a class action on behalf of other members of the Tumble Creek Club. Gutschmidt, who moved out of State and resigned her membership nearly two years ago, remains for all practical purposes a member of the club and continues to be charged membership dues and still has not had her membership deposit returned. The Complaint alleges among other things that Tumble Creek’s Membership Agreement as currently in place makes it practically impossible for a member to actually ever leave the club, to stop being charged monthly dues, or to have their membership deposit returned, a deposit that can be as much as $60,000. Under the terms of the Membership Agreement, Tumble Creek can hold onto a person’s membership deposit for 30 years or more, as further detailed in the Complaint. Taking a line from Hotel California, the Complaint begins with: ““‘Relax,’ said the night man, ‘We are programmed to receive. You can check out any time you like, but you can never leave.’”  “That well known refrain sums up what Tumble Creek members face if they ever try to resign their membership with the club.” says Jeffrey Possinger, one of the attorneys representing Gutschmidt. Tumble Creek Golf, LLC, the company that runs Tumble Creek Club, is a country club at the center of a destination mountain community located 80 miles from Seattle on the Eastside of the Cascade mountains in Cle Elum, Washington. Tumble Creek is an exclusive community and golf club located within Suncadia. In addition to the Consumer Protection Act claims, the Complaint also seeks a judgment holding that some of the terms of Tumble Creek’s Membership Agreement are unenforceable.   About Possinger Law Group, PLLC Founded in 2001, Possinger Law Group is a boutique law firm dedicated to elite levels of service to small and medium-sized businesses and the individuals that own them. When faced with serious problems, clients have reached out to Possinger Law Group to be a trusted advisor and advocate to be a guide through high conflict situations and complex legal challenges. In litigation matters, Possinger Law Group works with its clients to effectively resolve disputes, and when necessary, by being fiercely aggressive in litigation. More Information For more information, news, and updates about the Tumble Creek Class Action Lawsuit, please visit our case website. For media questions, interviews, or any other needs, please contact: [email protected]   = = = = = References: Order Granting Gutschmidt’s Motion to Amend Pleadings First Amended Complaint

Court Grants MJ Management’s Motions for Summary Judgement Against Defendants Scott Hillius and Mark Miedema

Posted on: 19 Oct 2026

Bellingham, WA Following a hearing on Friday, October 16, 2026, in Whatcom County Superior Court, the court granted MJ Management’s Motions for Summary Judgment in two collection actions brought against Homestead homeowners Scott Hillius and Mark Miedema. The judgments cover amounts owed to MJ Management during the period in which it operated under a Management and Lease Agreement with 18 Paradise, LP, the former owner of the Homestead Golf Course. Both Hillius and Miedema, represented by K. David Andersson, raised a number of defenses that the court rejected. Specifically, in Hillius’s case, the defendant failed to provide any evidence to refute MJ Management’s Motion for Summary Judgment. The court entered orders in both cases and granted MJ Management’s request to bring motions for attorney’s fees. Both successful motions were argued by attorney Ian Ducey, an associate attorney at Possinger Law Group. The court agreed that there was ample evidence to establish that 18 Paradise’s assignment to MJ Management of the right to collect joint maintenance fees also included the authority to pursue legal action to collect those fees. This assignment was subsequently affirmed by 18 Paradise’s successor in interest, IMM Capital Advisors. Both Hillius and Miedema are class representatives in the Hillius v. 18 Paradise litigation and have, to date, refused to pay any joint maintenance fees associated with Homestead since the litigation began. Attorneys K. David Andersson and Matthew Davis, who represent parties in the Hillius litigation, have also represented nonpaying Homestead homeowners in collection actions while simultaneously representing certain class members who claim they are owed refunds for overpayments. “These differing positions create a very odd situation as these cases proceed,” says attorney Jeffrey Possinger. “But here, the court got this right as to nonpaying homeowners.” Judge David Freeman’s order in the Hillius litigation, entered on September 11, 2024, found the Sixth and Seventh Amendments void but affirmed that the previously imposed $36.00 monthly joint maintenance fee was proper and owing. Possinger Law Group represents MJ Management in its efforts to collect the amounts that remain unpaid pursuant to Judge Freeman’s order. “Judge Grochmal’s decision today clears the way for collecting the remaining amounts owing by nonpaying Homestead homeowners, including the right to collect attorney’s fees from those who choose to fight,” Possinger added. Motions for attorney’s fees in the Hillius and Miedema cases are expected to be filed in the coming days.   Case Update (10/20/2026) On October 20, 2026, attorney David K. Andersson filed two Motions for Reconsideration of Judge Grochmal’s October 16 decisions in the Hillius case (WCSC #26-2-00712-37) and the Miedema case (WCSC #26-2-00713-37). The following day, October 21, 2026, the court denied both motions. In its decision on the Hillius case, the court stated, in part: “18 Paradise assigned all of its right, title and interest in and to the Declarant Rights to IMM Capital Advisors, Inc., on September 26, 2025. Before that time, 18 Paradise had already assigned some Declarant Rights to MJ Management, as determined by Judge Freeman in his Findings of Fact, Conclusions of Law, and Order on Remaining Claims, filed September 11, 2024 in Hillius v. 18 Paradise, 20-2-00701-37. Subsequently, IMM acknowledged, in writing via the Declaration of Sugn Han filed in this case on September 28, 2026, that at the time of the Assignment of Declarant Rights from 18 Paradise to IMM, 18 Paradise had already assigned certain declarant rights to MJ Management, and IMM acknowledged that it would not be collecting outstanding dues from January 2018 – May 2023. This Court on October 16, 2026, found that this acknowledgement was sufficient to find that the verbal assignment of rights to MJ Management for that time period was valid despite the lack of writing, because IMM acknowledged that it would not have the authority to collect dues for that time period, and because 18 Paradise assigned all of its remaining declarant rights, as of September 26, 2025, to IMM and would therefore not have the right to collect. RCW 4.08.080, Unifund CCR Partners v. Sunde, 163 Wash. App. 473 (2011). Defendant’s Motion to Reconsider is denied without Reply or oral argument per WCCR 59.” In its decision on the Miedema case, the court stated, in part: “This matter is related to the case of MJ Management v. Scott Hillius (26-2-000712-37. MJ Management is represented by the same attorney in both cases, and the Defendants are both represented by the same attorney.” The court further explained that no additional action was necessary in Miedema’s case because there was no pending motion to dismiss. The court noted that, had such a motion been pending, it likely would have been denied for the same reasons the court denied Hillius’s motion to dismiss that day. Both Hillius and Miedema subsequently filed identical Motions for Reconsideration of the court’s October 16, 2026, ruling. The court denied Hillius’s Motion for Reconsideration on the merits. The court denied Miedema’s Motion for Reconsideration because no decision had been made on the issue in his case and, therefore, there was nothing to reconsider.   About Possinger Law Group, PLLC Founded in 2001, Possinger Law Group is a boutique law firm dedicated to providing exceptional service to small and medium-sized businesses and the individuals who own them. Clients facing serious challenges turn to Possinger Law Group for trusted advice and advocacy, particularly when navigating high-conflict situations and complex legal matters. In litigation, Possinger Law Group works closely with clients to resolve disputes effectively and, when necessary, advocates aggressively on their behalf in court. Possinger Law Group represented MJ Management throughout the trial in the Hillius v. 18 Paradise litigation and continues to represent MJ Management in its efforts to collect unpaid Joint Maintenance Fees.   = = = = = References: Order Granting Summary Judgment (Scott Hillius) (TBD) Order Granting Summary Judgment (Mark Miedema) (TBD) Order Denying Motion for Reconsideration (Hillius) Order Denying Motion for Reconsideration (Miedema)

Court Stays Tumble Creek Club’s Motion for Summary Judgment

Posted on: 15 Aug 2026

Ellensburg, WA Following a contentious hearing on Friday, August 14, 2026, the court granted Plaintiff Penny Gutschmidt’s motion for a continuance of Tumble Creek Golf’s Motion for Summary Judgement that was scheduled to be heard that day. Both Gutschmidt’s Motion to Certify a Class and Tumble Creek Golf’s Motion for Summary Judgment were schedule to be heard by Judge James Kirkham in Kittitas County Superior Court that day, but because of information provided by Tumble Creek Club in discovery only days before the hearing, Gutschmidt requested that the court grant her more time to address the fact that during the pendency of the motions, Suncadia Resort and Escalante Golf had completed a transaction that included the sale of the Tumble Creek Club and its membership agreements to an affiliate business of Escalante Golf (Escalante Tumble Creek, LLC). In response to this late breaking information, much of it previously withheld by Tumble Creek Club, Gutschmidt filed a number of motions within days; a CR 56(f) Motion to Continue and a Motion for Leave to Amend Pleadings (to name the new buyers of the Tumble Creek Club). As argued in her motion for a continuance, the relief being sought by Gutschmidt in her complaint against Tumble Creek Golf under the Washington Consumer Protection Act Ch. 19.86 RCW, not only includes money damages claims, but also declaratory and injunctive relief with respect to the Tumble Creek Club’s Membership Plan, which had been sold to Escalante Tumble Creek, LLC as part of Suncadia Resort and Escalante Golf’s transaction; and the absence of these parties from the litigation would prevent Gutschmidt and any certified class from obtaining complete relief. The court agreed. After hearing evidence surrounding the sale of the Tumble Creek Club and Tumble Creek Golf’s submissions to the court in support of its Motion for Summary Judgement, the court granted Gutschmidt’s motion for a continuance, and Tumble Creek Golf withdrew its Motion for Summary Judgment to be refiled at a later date; the court it its order determined that any future Motion for Summary Judgment by Tumble Creek Golf could not be brought sooner that 120 days from the entry of the Order. [Link to Order]. Because of these new developments, Gutschmidt also withdrew her Motion for Certification of a Class until all necessary parties could be before the court.  Shortly thereafter, Gutschmidt also withdrew her Motion for Leave to Amend Pleadings to be re-noted for a later date. Gutschmidt is expected to re-note her Motion for Leave to Amend Pleadings in the near future.   About Possinger Law Group, PLLC Founded in 2001, Possinger Law Group is a boutique law firm dedicated to elite levels of service to small and medium-sized businesses and the individuals that own them. When faced with serious problems, clients have reached out to Possinger Law Group to be a trusted advisor and advocate to be a guide through high conflict situations and complex legal challenges. In litigation matters, Possinger Law Group works with its clients to effectively resolve disputes, and when necessary, by being fiercely aggressive in litigation. For More Information about the Tumble Creek Class Action: For more information, news, and updates about the Tumble Creek Class Action Lawsuit, visit our case website. For media questions, interviews, or any other needs, please contact: [email protected]   = = = = = References: Order Granting Gutschmidt’s CR 56(f) Motion to Continue

MJ Management Continues its Winning Streak in Homestead Collection Cases

Posted on: 05 May 2026

On May 1, 2026, the court entered an order granting MJ Management’s Motion for Summary Judgment in the case of MJ Management v. Korthuis, (Whatcom Cty. Sup. Ct. No. 25-2-02690-37). The decision entered by Whatcom Superior Court Judge, Lee Grochman, granted MJ Management’s request for a judgment requiring payment of unpaid Joint Maintenance Fees in the amount of $3,022.47, and directed MJ Management to bring a Motion for Attorney’s fees. Like the Court’s decision in the Kelly case, the Court rejected the Defendant’s various attempts to defend against MJ Management’s collection efforts on complicated and technical readings of the law and the Homestead PRD.   At the hearing, attorney Matt Davis, for the Defendant, raised a number of last-minute affirmative defenses during oral argument, which the Court determined to be untimely.  In a similar way, the Court rejected Mr. Davis’s arguments that MJ Management lacked a basis for its attorney’s fees and costs. Those were authorized as part of Judge Grochmal’s final orders on Summary Judgment.  “It seems that the various defendants and their counsel in these collection actions by homeowners that stopped paying during the Hillius case simply want to continue litigating that case, which ended almost two years ago,” stated Jeffrey Possinger, one of the attorneys for MJ Management in the Hillius trial in May 2024, and attorney for the law firm now leading collection actions on behalf of MJ Management. “We are now simply doing our part to help settle accounts consistent with Judge Freeman’s decision in Hillius,” he said.  Attorney, Ian Ducey, from the law firm has represented MJ Management in its collection efforts and successfully argued the Motions for Summary Judgment in both the Kelly Case and the Korthuis Case. 

Court Decision Settles Outstanding Issues in MJ Management’s Favor

Posted on: 23 Mar 2026

On March 18, 2026, the court entered an order granting MJ Management’s Motion for Summary Judgment in the case of MJ Management v. Kelly, (Whatcom Count Sup. Ct. No. 25-2-02688-37). The decision entered by Judge Jennifer Slattery, both granted MJ Management’s request for a judgment requiring payment of unpaid Joint Maintenance Fees by the Defendant but also resolved a number of legal questions that remained unanswered by the court over the last few years. The decision established MJ Management’s right to collect unpaid Joint Maintenance Fees during the time that MJ Management operated at Homestead under its Management and Lease Agreement, as well as its right to attorney’s fees and costs. Equally important was the court’s sound rejection of various defenses that had been raised by Kelly’s legal counsel, which had been communicated to Homestead homeowners in the months following the decision in years-long Hillius v. 18 Paradise litigation. A copy of the Motion can be found at the bottom of this article.  The Defendant, Kelly, was represented by attorneys Matthew Davis and K. David Andersson, the same attorneys that had represented class members in the Hillius litigation. For over a year since the entry of final orders in that case, several of the class representatives and their counsel had raised objections to MJ Management’s right to collect unpaid Joint Maintenance Fees and continued to encourage homeowners to refuse to pay the amounts they owned. The Court’s decision in MJ Management v. Kelly soundly rejected these arguments and clears the way to MJ Management’s collection of the remaining amounts owing along with a right to its attorney’s fees and costs under the Homestead CC&Rs.  The Motion for Summary Judgment was argued before Judge Slattery on February 202, 2026, by attorney Ian Ducey from Possinger Law Group for MJ Management, and attorney Matthew Davis on behalf of Defendant, Kelly, with a large number of Homestead residents watching via Zoom.  In its decision, the Court noted that “no evidence raising a genuine issue of material fact was provided by [the] Defendant.” And went on to rule that “…[o]wners of units within the Island Green Commons Condominium are subject to the Homestead [CC&Rs]…”   The Court ruled that the Condominium and its units were “residential platted area[s]” subject to the CC&Rs…,” soundly rejected the arguments raised by Kelly’s counsel. During oral argument, attorney Matthew Davis also conceded that the other condominiums located within Homestead PRD were covered by the Homestead CC&Rs. “Their argument here was the same ‘stealth legal theory’ that the Plaintiffs had previously attempted to bring into the Hillius trial but which was dismissed by the trial judge.” stated attorney, Jeffrey Possinger, who represented MJ Management in the Hillius litigation. “It is satisfying to have this issued finally resolved and finally put to bed.”   Most significant in the Court’s order was the determination that 18 Paradise had assigned the right to collect Joint Maintenance Fees to MJ Management from January 1, 2018 to May 31, 2023, and was authorized to collect unpaid balances incurred by Homestead homeowners during that time period. The court’s order granted MJ Management’s right to collect attorney’s fees and costs and directed MJ Management to bring a declaration for attorney’s fees within 14 days of the court’s order.  Possinger Law Group represented MJ Management in the Hillis v. 18 Paradise litigation through the trial and has continued to represent MJ Management in its efforts to collect unpaid Joint Maintenance Fees.    CASE UPDATES (05/05/2026) Since the entry of the Court’s decision on March 18, 2025, there have been numerous case developments. Motion for Reconsideration Denied.  Following the entry of the decision on summary judgment, Defendant’s counsel brought a Motion for Reconsideration, essentially rearguing the same positions that the Court had previously rejected, and raising some issues based on Defendant’s counsel having taken the time to read some of the earlier court filings more closely. All of these arguments to reverse the Court’s decision in the favor of MJ Management were ultimately unpersuasive and Judge Slattery denied the motion.  A copy of the Order denying Kelly’s Motion for Reconsideration is available below. MJ Management Awarded Attorneys Fees and Costs.  While Kelly’s Motion for Reconsideration was pending, MJ Management brought its motion for attorney’s fees and costs as directed by the Court. A day after denying Kelly’s Motion for Reconsideration, the Court granted MJ Management’s request for attorney’s fees and costs over Plaintiff’s counsel’s objections.  Kelly’s objections were essentially attempts to re-argue the previously failed arguments from the Motion for Summary Judgment, which were soundly repudiated by the decision to deny reconsideration.   In the end, the Court awarded MJ Management $3,780.09 for unpaid Joint Maintenance Fees and $20,052.56 in attorney’s fees and costs. The Court ordered that fees and costs be paid in the next 30 days. Even though Kelly and her counsel vigorously argued that “the legal system could not function if it charge almost five time the amount in controversy to resolve disputes,” MJ Management pointed out that this concern is a significant factor in why contracts contain fee shifting provisions, and that “parties must evaluate whether a breach is worth the risk if they must pay the prevailing parties’ fees,” and the Court agreed and awarded MJ Management’s fees and costs.  MJ Management Continues Winning Streak in Korthuis Case.  While the various issues in the Kelly case were pending, MJ Management has continued to move forward with another companion case: MJ Management v. Korthuis, Whatcom Cty. Sup. Ct. #25-2-02690-37. On May 1, 2026, Whatcom County Superior Court Judge, Lee Grochmal, granted MJ Management’s Motion for Summary Judgment on similar facts to those in Kelly. The Defendant in that raised many of the same defenses that were raised in Kelly, and like the case in Kelly the Court rejected those arguments and decided in favor of MJ Management in its attempts to collect unpaid Joint Maintenance Fees. More information on the Korthuis case can be found here. Attorney, Ian Ducey, from Possinger Law Group, successfully argued for MJ Management’s Motions for Summary Judgment in both the Kelly and Korthuis cases.  Possinger Law Group Posts FAQs  In response to what appears to be a significant amount of confusion and misinformation circulating within the Homestead community, Possinger Law Group recently posted some FAQ’s in the hopes of bringing some clarity to MJ Management’s efforts to collect unpaid Joint Maintenance Fees.   “Relying on legal advice that you get from ‘the Internet’ is always a risky strategy,” says Jeffrey Possinger, attorney at Possinger Law Group.  “As well-intentioned as many Homestead homeowners […]